Thursday, April 17, 2014

The Infinite Art Tournament Second-Round Elimination: Giorgione v. Giulio Romano!


Leaving the Tournament this week are two guys who could beat Gilbert and George, but who lost their other two matches. Both Giambologna and Harold Gilman get leave us with records of 1-2, Giambologna (14 cumulative votes for, 20 against) falling to Giorgione and Gilman (14-23) overpowered by Giulio Romano.

The other thing that Giorgione and Giulio Romano have in common, besides Italian heritage, the years 1492 to 1510 (Giorgione was a grown-up, Giulio Romano was a kid), and haven beaten the guys who beat Gilbert and George, is that they are the two artists that Giotto beat on the way to his Third Round match with Giacometti. The old-school Florentine beat Giulio Romano 8-3 and Giorgione 6-4. Do those numbers imply that Giorgione has a big edge in this contest? If you've watched Tournament results for long, you'll know that it doesn't always work like that!




Giorgione
c. 1477 - 1510
Italian
  • Beat Luca Giordano by a two-vote spread in Round 1. YOUR VOTE COUNTS!!
  • Lost to Giotto in Round 2 by a two-vote spread. YOUR VOTE COUNTS!!
  • Beat sculptor Giambologna in the Left Bracket Second Round by several votes. Which is not to say that your vote doesn't count.





Giulio Romano
1492 - 1546
Italian





Vote for the artist of your choice in the comments, or any other way that works for you. Commentary and links to additional work are welcome. Polls open for at least one month past posting, but likely much longer.

11 comments:

Christine M. said...

Giorgione

Chuckdaddy said...

The battle of the Gilbert and George-killers killers! I'll go with Giulio.

DrSchnell said...

abstain.

Elizabeth said...

Giorgione.

Morgan said...

I'll vote Giulio for the room. I like Giorgione, though, and would have had no qualms voting for him in a different matchup.

pfly said...

Giulio Romano. Collapsing columns get me every time.

mrs.5000 said...

Yeah, now I remember why I'm behind on my voting. This is a killer. I really like Giorgione, but will back the virtuoso Giulio Romano in this one.

lamanyana said...

Giorgione

Michael5000 said...

I guess I'll go with Giulio Romano's neato room. Neither one fires me up especially...

Candida said...

Giulio!

Michael5000 said...

Allrighty, it looks like it's Giulio Romano over Giorgione, 6 to 3. Thanks for voting!